Security Comparison of Various Surgical Knots Using Nylon Suture

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the strengths of various surgical knot techniques, including square knot, surgeon's knot, granny knot, and random knot with the same three throws. METHODS: The authors tested each of the four knot techniques using four different gauges of nylon (polyamide [Ethicon]): 4-0, 5-0, 6-0, and 7-0. Each knot type was tested 20 times per nylon gauge, for a total of 320 knots tested. The authors used a static pull machine to measure elongation at yield and maximal force to break. RESULTS: A comparison of elongation at yield revealed that the surgeon's knot was superior to the square knot, granny knot, and random knots across all gauges of nylons. Further, a comparison of maximal force to break revealed that the surgeon's knot was superior to the square knot, granny knot, and random knots when using 4-0, 5-0, and 6-0 nylon but not when using 7-0 nylon. CONCLUSIONS: The surgeon's knot was the strongest, and random knot was the weakest when the authors used nylon 4-0, 5-0, and 6-0. While handling fine suture materials such as 7-0 nylon, knot failure appears to be unrelated to the knot technique used. This study provides not only fundamental guidance for tying surgical knots using nylon, but also a rational basis for an adequately strong knot choice in various fields of surgery.